Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

Marxism or Marxisms: Challenges in Addressing Marxian Thought in History of Economic Thought Textbooks.

A P SREERAJ, Thunchath Ezhuthachan Malayalam University

Marxism is a diverse intellectual tradition encompassing multiple schools of thought. This study examines how two widely used History of Economic Thought textbooks—The Wealth of Ideas by Alessandro Roncaglia (2005) and A Concise History of Economic Thought by Gianni Vaggi and Peter Groenewegen (2006)—address class and determinism in Marxist thought. Both textbooks present Marx as employing a rigid two-class framework, overlooking his nuanced approach. While Capital (Volume III) contains a brief discussion on class, Marx’s broader work employs a multi-class framework based on surplus labor as he defined the class process as “unpaid surplus labour is pumped out of direct producers” (Marx,1867). Contrary to the textbooks' claims, Marxist theorists worldwide have developed alternative classifications using property, power, surplus labor, or a composite framework that included various mixtures of the above-mentioned three criteria. For instance, John Mencher (1974) classified agrarian classes in India based on land ownership, while C. Wright Mills (1956) categorized elites in the U.S. using power. Nicos Poulantzas (1978) introduced a composite model incorporating economic, political, and ideological dimensions. Additionally, both textbooks portray Marxism as economically deterministic, reducing all social processes to the economic base. While Marx used base-superstructure determinism in Capital (Volume I) only twice, his Grundrisse suggests that his method of analysis is more dynamic in nature. Althusser’s concept of "over-determination" further challenges deterministic interpretations. By failing to engage with these complexities, these textbooks offer a limited representation of Marxist thought. A deeper exploration of class and determinism would provide a more comprehensive and intellectually rigorous understanding of Marxism

Area:

Keywords: Marxism, Class, Base-Superstructure, Determinism

Please Login in order to download this file