Personal identity as a second-order right in a socially stratified world: Parfit, Korsgaard, Sen, and Du Bois and Fanon
This paper argues people ought to have a right to manage their personal identities throughout their lives. It first discusses the principle that rights expand individual freedoms and a problem with it. It then argues identity management should be seen as a second-order right that overarches standard first-order rights. To explain the concept of personal identity the thinking of Parfit and Korsgaard’s views are reviewed. Whether and when people develop personal identities is addressed using Sen’s capability approach. Du Bois and Fanon’s concept of double consciousness is employed to explain how social stratification limits personal identity formation for some individuals. This analysis produces an individual ‘rights reconciliation problem’ regarding why people in managing their personal identities freely choose reductions in some freedoms to which they may have rights. The paper argues progressive social policy promotes freedom when it focuses on those most in need, the socially most vulnerable and the personally most precarious.
Area:
Keywords: rights, freedom, personal identity, Parfit, Korsgaard, Sen, Du Bois, Fanon, social stratification, rights reconciliation, human precarity
Please Login in order to download this file