Franz Neumann and the Political Economy of Monopoly Capitalism
German scholar Franz Leopold Neumann (1900-1954) has almost exclusively been cast as a political theorist and lawyer, yet most of his work speaks to economic themes and often draws from the canon of liberal political economy. From his article “Economics and Politics in the 20th century” to “The Fate of Small Business in Nazi Germany,” Neumann’s work has explicitly engaged economics and its relationship with political institutions. This article seeks to place Neumann within the context not of political theory or legal studies but in the history of economics. As a Jewish scholar, (unorthodox) Marxist intellectual, and Weimar jurist of labor law, Neumann faced a triplex of factors that made his escape from Germany a great feat. Neumann was a scholar-in-exile at the London School of Economics during the 1930s before later immigrating to the United States and working for the Office of Strategic Services (OSS). While not often cited in economics, his work was engaged by such figures as F. A. Hayek and Harold Laski, and he was in the same conversations as John Kenneth Galbraith and Vilfredo Pareto. In his interpretive work and lectures, Neumann distinctly engaged with classical liberal figures such as Smith, Locke, and Montesquieu. Further, Neumann engaged in modern and practical statistical and historical research. Regulatory capture, oligopolistic bargaining, and the failures of command economies were not abstract concerns for Neumann but rather concretely based on empirical evidence. Neumann’s masterpiece, Behemoth: The Structure and Practice of National Socialism, 1933-1944 was a groundbreaking study of Nazi political economy but is not often cited by economists. Neumann’s assessment of Nazi political economy was, firstly, one that furnished groundbreaking data on the economic situation in Germany in the 1930s and 40s, and secondly, used economic theory to diagnose a crumbling of the Nazi regime, not only because it was legally dubious and politically corrupt, but in particular because it violated freedom of contract and basic economic laws. In general, Neumann's contributions centered on the relationship between political, legal, and economic institutions, and, in particular, his concerns were over the formation of monopolies and cartels, which would influence subsequent discussions of the ‘military-industrial complex' today.
Area:
Keywords: Franz Neumann, Monopoly Capitalism, Cartels, Labor Law
Please Login in order to download this file