Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

“Luxury and Virtue After the Enlightenment: Mexico, 1810-1854”

Frith Eric, University of Houston

Luxury was a contentious idea in eighteenth-century Europe. From Fénelon and Mandeville to Rousseau and Smith, the debate on its nature and effects, moral and political, ran for generations. Indeed, in 1762, the entry on “Luxury” for the Encyclopédie presented it as “the central moral and political issue of modernity.” By the end of the century, however, the contest apparently had been settled. In 1786, the Abbé Pluquet conceded that “Mandeville’s ideas had effectively dissolved the moral and theological connotations of the term.” The debate was also surveyed and declared settled at the Spanish court. In 1788 Juan Sempere y Guarinos concluded that luxury was nothing but the natural effect of abundance, and the debate itself largely the result of a poorly framed question conflating the moral and political spheres. But in Spanish America the luxury debates were not dead. As Rebecca Earle has written, luxury and excess were often central elements in both the European perception of Spanish American society, and in Spanish American elites’ definitions of civilization and modernity. I show that in early nineteenth-century Mexico, two important thinkers continued to explore the theme in the urgent context of Mexico’s wars of independence. Juan Wenceslao Barquera, a somewhat obscure legal thinker, developed the theme of luxury and virtuous citizenship in his draft constitutions for the new republic, and in his pro-independence newspaper El Mentor mexicano, named for the character in Fénelon’s Les aventures de Télémaque. A much better-known writer, the essayist and publicist José Joaquin Fernandez de Lizardi—sometimes known as Spanish America’s first novelist—also explored the relationship between luxury and civic virtue in his El Periquillo sarniento. I show that both Mexican writers found the connection between luxury and civic virtue a vital point of public discussion amidst the upheavals of the early nineteenth century, as Mexico’s print and political cultures began to take shape. Moreover, I show that the questions they raised and the imagery they employed in the early nineteenth century reappeared in the middle of the century, in the magnum opus of Mexico’s most pivotal statesman and political thinker, Lucas Alamán. Alamán’s Historia de Méjico, begun during his year in hiding and after his withdrawal from public office, drew on the language of Barquera and Lizardi to decry the “private opulence and public penury” of a nation on the precipice.

Area:

Keywords: Luxury debate; Spanish America; Nineteenth century; war; republicanism; liberalism

Please Login in order to download this file