Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

Red and Economists? Conflicting Scientific Paradigms in Chinese Economics under Maoism

Chenard Antonin, EHESS

Alongside the transition towards a socialist planned economy, Chinese economics experienced a radical transformation starting in the 1950s. More than a mere adjustment to the new structures and functioning of the economic system, the discipline had to adapt to a whole new scientific paradigm imposed by the Chinese Communist Party (CCP). Drawing on the main academic journal in economics of the early Maoist era, Jingji Yanjiu (published between 1955 and 1966), this research explores how the CCP tried to transform economics and how economists faced these new constraints. From the idea that science could not be apolitical, the new power questioned all the dimensions of the work of economists. However, this study shows that the boundaries of the new legitimate knowledge and practices were not fixed and evolved alongside political events. Topics of research or methods used could shift depending on the balance of political power at home, whereas academic relations with foreign economists were strongly influenced by geopolitical developments. Similarly, economic literature was segmented based on political criteria, and especially according to the country it originated from. The close entanglement between politics and research materialized in the daily work of economists through basic issues such as the access to government data or the opportunity to produce recommendations for economic policy. Economists nonetheless found ways to comply without completely abandoning their prior research. But those who openly voiced their complaints were severely criticized both by top officials and by some of their own colleagues, as in 1957 when some economists published an op-ed criticizing the regime’s policies towards science. Economists from an older generation educated in Western universities were much more reluctant to comply with the new rules than their younger counterparts trained in Soviet or CCP's universities. Ultimately, the CCP’s constraints on economists were part of a broader campaign to discipline intellectuals, a population towards which the regime had a negative view. The CCP attempted to favor the emergence of scientists both "red and expert" (youhong youzhuan), that is individuals both aligned with the Party's ideology and able to provide the expertise it initially lacked when seizing power. Although economists seemed willing to work for the new regime, some were seen by the CCP as not "red" enough to be associated to its effort to transform China. The new scientific paradigm was thus also an attempt to transform economists themselves to fit the CCP's ideals and needs.

Area:

Keywords: Chinese economic thought; intellectuals; maoism; politicization of science; socialist economics

Please Login in order to download this file