Understanding Tibor Scitovsky's Opposition to Consumer Sovereignty
This article provides an interpretation of Tibor Scitovsky’s opposition to "consumer sovereignty" from 1960 to the 1990s. The first part of the article shows how, during the 1960s, Scitovsky came to identify the endogeneity of preferences as a problem for welfare economics. This led him to search for a criterion that would make it possible to distinguish legitimate influences on preferences from problematic ones, without breaking with consumer subjectivity. The third part demonstrates how The Joyless Economy (1976) represents the culmination of this line of reasoning, leading Scitovsky to advocate consumer education as a means of informing preferences. The importance he assigns to the “generalist” consumer — that is, an informed and therefore "effective" consumer — as a way of conceptualizing consumer interest implies recourse to a normative standard that distinguishes preferences revealed through choice from deeper preferences that genuinely maximize consumer welfare. The way Scitovsky identifies a gap between consumers’ welfare and their choices — drawing on psychological research — raises the question of the correct interpretation of The Joyless Economy, which has become a reference in both behavioral economics and happiness economics. By stressing the role played by the concept of "personality" in The Joyless Economy and shifting the focus from the opposition between comfort and stimulation to that between "skilled" and "unskilled" stimulation, this article aims to shed new light on Scitovsky’s thought.
Area:
Keywords: History of Welfare Economics, Preferences, Consumer Sovereignty
Please Login in order to download this file