Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

Harrod Beyond Harrod: Investment Determinants, Technical Progress, and Expectations

Linguanti Francesco, University of Siena

This paper explores the possibility of a long-run formalization of Harrodian macrodynamics, reclaiming its originally cyclical orientation. One of Harrod’s most influential contributions was to combine Kahn’s multiplier with J. M. Clark’s accelerator into a single analytical framework. As Kregel (1980) notes, however, the purpose of this “marriage” is often forgotten: to address expansions and depressions—hence the cycle—not as deviations from a static equilibrium, but as oscillations around a line of steady advance. Building on the interpretive contributions of Kregel, Asimakopulos, and Besomi, the paper stresses a crucial methodological distinction in Harrod’s theory: the presence of two distinct analytical problems that the literature has frequently blurred. On the one hand, Harrod develops an analysis of steady growth at a constant rate (the “first part”), most clearly articulated in the 1939 Essay. On the other hand, he aims to understand the joint dynamics of multiplier and accelerator around a long-run trend (the “second part”), more closely associated with The Trade Cycle (1936). As the aforementioned authors show, disentangling these two aspects was far from straightforward and generated misunderstandings even among Harrod’s contemporaries, as suggested by the correspondence between Harrod and Keynes. The consequences were not trivial: such ambiguities deeply shaped the subsequent post-Keynesian theory of growth. The paper focuses on the “second part,” which in Harrod takes a form that is less fully rigorous from an analytical standpoint, yet appears decisive for a coherent theory of the cycle. A major outcome of a simplified post-Keynesian reading has been to treat the warranted rate as a single growth rate, neglecting the possibility—explicitly envisaged by Harrod—that it may vary over the course of the cycle. This interpretive shift encouraged strong assumptions, such as a constant output–capacity ratio or the existence of a “normal” rate of capacity utilization that is fixed and exogenous. Making the “second part” more rigorous therefore means, in line with Besomi (1995), restoring centrality to the determinants of investment and confronting one of the most ambitious challenges in macrodynamics: acknowledging the accelerator as a determinant while endogenizing its operation. The paper develops this agenda along two lines. The first concerns technical progress, understood as a force that changes the productivity of capital and labour and thus shapes the trajectory of capital accumulation both in competitive economies and in contexts marked by high capital concentration. The second line proposes a way to model long-run expectations, assuming they are not independent of the frustration of short-run expectations. From this perspective, any formalization of Harrod’s cyclical theory—where analysis is not confined to a single point in time but incorporates temporal processes—must explicitly include the formation and revision of expectations.

Area:

Keywords: Harrodian macrodynamics, trade cycle, capacity utilization, post-Keynesian growth theory

Please Login in order to download this file