[YSP] Calculators on the Countryside: Ag Econ Takes Root in Progressive Era America
This paper draws from Chapter 1 of my PhD dissertation, "Calculating the Countryside: Economists and the Remaking of Rural America." It narrates the founding of agricultural economics as a discipline in the early 20th century, focusing in particular on the figure of Henry C. Taylor and his intellectual network located at the University of Wisconsin-Madison and the American Midwest more broadly. Other figures discussed in this paper include Richard T. Ely, Benjamin Hibbard, Warren J. Spillman, and both Henry Wallaces. I argue that the essence of agricultural economics in this founding period was to empower farm households and operate as a countervailing force against the growing influence of industrial interests. The pressures of urbanization, inequality, and rapid economic transformation spurred the creation of a discipline that sought to safeguard elements of American life long cherished and yet at risk (the middle-class, owner-operated, small to mid-sized family farm). Late 19th and early 20th century discursive contexts like the anti-monopoly movement, agrarian populism, Georgism, and land economics were important influences on agricultural economics as it first took root in the United States land-grant university system. Indeed, agricultural economics saw itself as a class-inflected pursuit, invested in maximizing farmer welfare against other classes of society. This obtains in the progressive and anti- laissez faire politics of many of agricultural economics’ first generation thinkers. Nevertheless, the paper also explores the social conservatism and anti-immigrant sentiment inherent in many of their economic visions, serving as the submerged "political limits" of their epistemological horizons. Ultimately, the paper demonstrates how explicitly opposed to industrial agriculture the leading intellectuals of American agrarian political economy were in the early 20th century. This serves as a marked contrast against the future trajectory of agricultural economics. By the postwar period, economists like Theodore Schultz and Zvi Griliches more openly embraced large-scale and corporate agriculture, informed by a very different political vision than their forbears. The paper concludes with a brief discussion of this future iteration, in order to more fully appreciate the distinctiveness of the early 20th century roots of agricultural economics in social reform, civic republicanism, and emotional proximity to the nation’s land and ecology.
Area:
Keywords: Agricultural Economics, Progressive Era, UW-Madison, Henry C. Taylor, Richard T. Ely