Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

The young Taylor as an old Keynesian: is the Taylor Rule a resurgence of the 1960s?

Pires Estevao, Université Paris 1

The 1990s marked the emergence of a new macroeconomic "mainstream", often described as the New Neoclassical Synthesis. A central component of this framework is the Taylor rule, introduced by John Taylor in 1993 as a simple interest-rate reaction function responding to deviations of inflation and output from their respective targets. The rule quickly became central both to monetary policy discussions within the U.S. Federal Reserve and to the architecture of emerging DSGE models. This paper examines the early work of the rule’s author, highlighting points of both continuity and rupture in his intellectual trajectory. It focuses on the late 1960s and early 1970s, a period of profound shifts within the discipline. The central research question is whether the Taylor rule should be interpreted as a break with Taylor’s early work or as a reformulation of an initial research agenda adapted to a radically transformed theoretical and methodological environment. By examining Taylor’s writings during the transition from the late 1960s to the 1970s, the paper documents a clear rupture at the level of modeling techniques and theoretical assumptions, notably through the introduction of rational expectations, the systematic use of linear-quadratic loss functions, and the exploration of increasingly complex optimal policy rules. These developments contrast sharply with the relative simplicity of the 1993 rule. Taylor started his economist’s career in a period marked by Keynesian stabilization models and the use of engineering techniques such as optimal control and feedback mechanisms. In his 1968 work, building on Phillips’s 1961 framework, Taylor employed control-theoretic tools to analyze the stabilization properties of alternative policy rules. Although the specific modeling frameworks underlying these contributions were progressively marginalized during the methodological upheavals of the 1970s, the paper argues that they articulated policy intuitions that are visible in his 1993 formulation. The paper intends to retrace not only the context of that period and debates about inflation, growth, stabilization but also the evolution of techniques and tools within the field. Beneath these methodological changes, core elements of Taylor’s early approach remained intact up to the final form of his rule. From this perspective, the Taylor rule appears less as the endpoint of a linear teleological progression than as the reactivation of policy ideas forged in the 1960s and reframed to fit the constraints and norms of a new macroeconomic "mainstream".

Area:

Keywords: History of Macroeconomics; Taylor Rule; Stabilization Policy; New Neoclassical Synthesis; 1960s Keynesianism

Please Login in order to download this file