DIVISION OF SCIENTIFIC LABOUR AND THE STRUCTURE OF ECONOMIC KNOWLEDGE
In The Wealth of Nations the role of division of labour is not confined to "improving dexterity". It involves a man into a network of exchange relationships, so that "far greater part of [useful things] he must derive from the labour of other people". However, while Smith's first statement applied to "every employment" including "philosophy or speculation", the scope of his second statement remained undefined. 250 years have passed, but the impact of the deepening specialisation of knowledge on its character and the interdependences within scientific community is still a largely neglected topic in HET. This paper attempts to rethink development trends in economics, taking into account the deepening division of scientific labour and its impact on the structure of knowledge. This approach sheds new light on the relationships between theory and practice, orthodoxy and heterodoxy, and the role of interdisciplinary research in social sciences. It is based on the analogy with the impact of division of labour on the structure of material production. It is known that the structure of social product, such as GDP, differs from the structure of economic activity, since the latter – unlike the former – includes production of intermediate products used during the same period. The deeper division of labour is, the more the gap between the two magnitudes. Has deepening division of scientific labour similar consequences? Is it possible to divide the outcomes of scientific work into final and intermediate, and if so, what are the relationships between the two? To answer these questions the paper traces back the evolution of the scope of economic ideas and their applications, as well as stages of the differentiation of economic knowledge. It is claimed that most of contemporary economic knowledge is intermediate by its nature, whereas final, or so called 'useful' knowledge, is highly dependent on it. Intermediate knowledge has two basic functions and takes two main forms. One form is that of Keynes's–Joan Robinson's–Rodrik's 'tool-kit'-type knowledge serving as root models ramified into specialised theories and models adapted for applied use. Another form is a knowledge providing 'common ground' for integration of narrow disciplinary and sub-disciplinary concepts indispensable in interdisciplinary projects, both basic and applied. This type of knowledge is analysed at the examples of Myrdal's "ex post/ex ante" distinction and Hirschman's "exit/voice" framework
Area:
Keywords: Structure of economic knowledge; history of differentiation of economic knowledge; division of scientific labour; economics and interdisciplinarity
Please Login in order to download this file