Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

[YSP] Ideas of Social justice among Liberal Scholars: the Case of Hayek and Einaudi

Lucchini Giorgia, Fondazione Luigi Einaudi Torino

Abstract Liberalism has always been concerned with freedom rather than equality, and therefore social justice. However, in twentieth century, the debate around the concept at stake was quite peculiar as the different economic, social, and political frameworks led to consider it from distinct perspectives (see Conway and Eirlichman 2024). Social justice was indeed not only a matter of philosophical and theoretical discussion but a concrete issue to deal with. Nowadays, there is instead a global growing demand for the dismantlement of the welfare state and the policies inspired by social justice. In particular, this kind of proposals have been advanced by populists who considered themselves heirs of Hayek and his fellows (Slobodian 2025). Therefore, in order to better comprehend and analyse the topic, as well as to foster suggestions in the current panorama, it seems useful to provide an account of how the theme of social justice was explored in the past by liberal scholars. Even though Friedrich Hayek and Luigi Einaudi can be both considered exponents of twentieth-century liberalism (although liberalisms are many) and they agreed on several matters, they had dissimilar ideas on social justice, how it works, and why we need it or not. While Hayek firmly rejected the concept of social justice (Hayek 1976), Einaudi was more opened to the possibility of admitting forms of social justice (Einaudi 1949). In addition to stress out the fact that the Einaudi-Hayek case is one example of disagreement on a macro topic among liberal scholars, the paper explores the reasons underlying the formation of their own convictions, including their cultural background and the concrete situations they faced. Both Hayek and Einaudi’s elaborations on the theme are beneficial for an in-depth understanding of the current account of social justice and provide insights on how to interpret and put in place it in a liberal way. Short references Conway, M., & Erlichman, C. (Eds.). (2024). Social justice in twentieth-century Europe. First edition. Cambridge University Press. Einaudi, L. (1949) Lezioni di politica sociale. Giulio Einaudi Hayek, F. A. von. (1976). The Mirage of Social Justice. Vol. 2 of Law, Legislation and Liberty: A New Statement of the Liberal Principles of Justice and Political Economy. University of Chicago Press. Slobodian, Q. (2025). Hayek's bastards: the neoliberal roots of the populist right. Random House.

Area:

Keywords: Liberalism, social justice, Hayek, Einaudi, equality

Please Login in order to download this file