Tackling Inheritance in Marxian Thought: the Contribution of Ecofeminism
Since the 1970s, developed economies have witnessed a "return of inheritance": the share of inherited wealth in household resources has recovered levels last seen in the nineteenth century, and remains highly concentrated. Despite this, the institution of inheritance occupies a paradoxical place in intellectual history — central to class reproduction, yet persistently naturalised, treated as an anthropological given rather than a politically constructed object. Surprisingly, it has also remained largely absent from contemporary philosophy and theories of justice. This article seeks to reconstruct the materialist critique of the familial transmission of wealth, tracing a lineage from the Saint-Simonians to Christine Delphy. The aim of this article is to trace the materialist critique of inheritance. The article establishes a long genealogy of the feminist and materialist critique of inheritance, running from the Saint-Simonian women of the 1830s through Engels, Bebel and Delphy. Its contemporary relevance is acute: private wealth concentration is approaching pre-WWI levels, and the coming "great wealth transfer" between generations makes the question of how, and for whom, wealth is transmitted more pressing than ever. Bazard and Enfantin's critique rests on three pillars: the French Revolution perpetuated the "skeleton of feudalism" by preserving hereditary property; inheritance acts as a "licence for idleness and exploitation" by allocating productive instruments to the best-born rather than the most capable; and property should become "property-as-function", allocated by a public authority according to merit — "To each according to his capacity, to each capacity according to its works." The Saint-Simonian women, organised around *La Femme Libre* (1832), went further than their male counterparts. Signing their texts with first names only — refusing the patronym as a political act — they showed that the transmission of property rests upon masculine authority. Their critique was proto-materialist: women's exclusion from patrimonial succession was not natural but the product of an arbitrary legal order (the Napoleonic Code). They were the first to connect inheritance explicitly to patriarchal domination, anticipating Engels by half a century. Marx diverges sharply from the Saint-Simonians on a fundamental point: inheritance is a juridical superstructure, not an economic infrastructure. August Bebel offers the most complete materialist treatment of inheritance, operating on three levels simultaneously. Philosophically, he formulates with precision the Marxian thesis: "In a socialist society there will be nothing to bequeath. Where private property does not exist, no right of inheritance can arise." *Historically*, he demonstrates that bourgeois marriage was constructed to produce "legitimate" heirs, and that suppressing inheritance would liberate relations between the sexes as well as economic relations. *Programmatically*, he was the co-architect of the Erfurt Programme (1891), which included a progressive inheritance tax as a concrete transitional demand — a legitimate instrument for reducing private property's capacity for intergenerational reproduction without waiting for full socialism. In 1977, Delphy performs a decisive analytical displacement: rather than treating inheritance merely as a vector of social reproduction (Bourdieu), she shows that it actively produces differentiation. By disaggregating the concept into three dimensions — filiation (symbolic and juridical hierarchisation), patrimony (material resources) and status (social positions) — she reveals that transmission is not reducible to the passage of goods between individuals; it is a mechanism that selects, excludes and assigns distinct social positions. These three dimensions do not necessarily overlap, which allows her to identify the specific social oppression that inheritance represents beyond its purely economic aspect.
Area:
Keywords: inheritance; marxian economics; feminism
Please Login in order to download this file