Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

“we wish to harvest fruits and not to plant flowers”: The Neo-Colbertiste phase of the Journal de l’agriculture, du commerce et des finances and the intellectual defeat of Physiocracy in the late Ancien Régime.

Ribeiro Leite Neto Fernando, INSPER - Learning and Research Institute
Mendes Catarino Nelson, UNICAMP - Economics Institute - University of Campinas

The editorial of the first issue of the Journal de l’agriculture, du commerce et des finances published in July 1765, stated that the aim of the journal was “the progress of economic knowledge” (1765, p. i). Having appeared as a monthly supplement to the Gazette du Commerce, the Journal presented itself as a space for more in-depth developments of arguments and reports. It was intended to be an editorial forum for economic debate in pre-Revolutionary France. Indeed, the editorial concludes with a powerful image: “(...) we wish to harvest fruits and not to plant flowers” (1765, p. vi). With Dupont de Nemours as editor from September 1765 to late 1766, the Journal became a mouthpiece for the ideas of Quesnay and Physiocracy. However, at the end of 1766, Dupont de Nemours was removed from the editorship and the Neo-Colbertist Véron de Forbonnais took over. Between February 1767 and May 1770, under Forbonnais the Journal became an important venue for criticism of Physiocratic ideas and a vehicle for the defense of mercantilism as conceived by the Neo-Colbertists. After losing control of the Journal, Dupont de Nemours edited the Éphémérides du Citoyen ou Bibliothèque raisonnée de l’histoire et de la morale et de la politique from early 1767 up to the closure of the journal by royal order in early 1772 transforming it into the new vehicle for the diffusion of Physiocratic thought. Both journals, therefore, represent spaces of economic debate in the final years of the Ancien Régime. On one hand, Physiocracy’s theories were and have been object of study in the field of economics historiography. On the other hand, in late eighteenth century France, Neo-Colbertism emerged victorious from the debate. As far as economic policy is concerned, Turgot’s failure in 1774 and 1776 with the liberalization of the internal grain trade constituted a setback for the Physiocrats’ liberal policies. Moreover, the themes of natural order and despotism were never theoretically resolved within Physiocracy. Hume, Smith, and even Rousseau accomplished the task of constructing a theoretical framework that articulated individual liberty with natural order. Defeated on both fronts, the Physiocrats nonetheless “harvest fruits” in the History of Economic Thought. However, there remain elements of the history of their failure at the end of the eighteenth century to be elucidated, and the Colbertist phase of the Journal de l’agriculture, du commerce et des finances may provide important contributions to that history.

Area:

Keywords: Physiocrats; Neo-Colbertistes; Journal de l'agriculture, du commerce et des finances; Eighteenth Century France; Ancien Régime

Please Login in order to download this file