Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

With Menger and Innes Towards a Complexity View of Money

Gschwandtner Jakob, JKU Linz

Carl Menger can be understood as a forerunner of complexity economics. His explanation of the origin of money serves as a paradigmatic example (Gloria 2025). By focusing on the spontaneous emergence of money, rather than its equilibrium properties, Menger’s account aligns with the main tenets of the complexity approach: social phenomena are explained as the outcome of actions by heterogeneous agents, who have incomplete knowledge, are boundedly rational and constantly adapt their strategies to their ever-changing environment (Arthur 2021). The present paper can therefore build on a two-fold conclusion. Menger’s explanation of the emergence of a medium of exchange in his Principles (1871 and his more general methodological considerations in his Investigations (1883) are highly relevant for modern complexity economics. Complexity economics, in turn, is promising for investigating the origin and the development of money. However, adopting a Mengerian complexity framework does not settle the substantial questions of monetary theory. To demonstrate this, the paper Alfred Mitchell Innes’ writings on the credit theory of money (1913, 1914). Three aspects are of particular importance. Firstly, even though Innes criticises the understanding of money as a medium of exchange, he most emphatically opposes the idea that the institution of money was created by a general agreement. Thus, despite their disagreement about the nature of money, Menger and Innes share a methodologically individualist approach towards monetary theory. Secondly, Innes’ notion of money as credit leads him to consider a more heterogeneous set of agents than Menger. Bartering individuals do not only differ with respect to their preferences and endowments; they differ in their ability to give credit. Furthermore, Innes’ account allows to seamlessly integrate banks and states as additional agents, which Menger only introduces post hoc. Thirdly, in Innes’ credit theory of money, credibility takes centre stage. This sheds light on a layer of uncertainty which is missing in Mengerian barter exchange. Expectations about the credit-worthiness of individuals, banks and states and the corresponding lack of complete knowledge appear as crucial aspects of monetary systems. All three aspects can be integrated into a (Mengerian) complexity perspective. Establishing the compatibility of Menger's and Innes' methodological commitments might pave the way for further progress in monetary theory. References: Arthur, W.B. 2021. “Foundations of complexity economics.” Nat Rev Phys 3, 136-145. Innes, Alfred Mitchell. 2004. [1913]. “What is Money?” In: Credit and State Theories of Money. The Contributions of A. Mitchell Innes. Edited by L Randall Wray. Edward Elgar Publishing Limited. Innes, Alfred Mitchell. 2004. [1914]. “The Credit Theory of Money.” In: Credit and State Theories of Money. The Contributions of A. Mitchell Innes. Edited by L Randall Wray. Edward Elgar Publishing Limited. Menger, Carl. 1934. [1871]. Grundsätze der Volkswirtschaftslehre. The Collected Works of Carl Menger, Volume 1. London Menger, Carl. 1933. [1883]. Untersuchungen ü.d. Methode der Socialwissenschaften u. der Politschen Ökonomie insbesondere. The Collected Works of Carl Menger, Volume 2. London Sandye, Gloria. 2025. “Emergence. Another Look at the Mengerian Theory of Money.” GREDEG Working Papers, Université de Côte d’Azur.

Area:

Keywords: Complexity, Emergence, Money, Methodological Individualism, Carl Menger, Alfred Mitchell Innes

Please Login in order to download this file