Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

Enhancing the Understanding of Lab-in-the-field experiments: Insights on the spectrum of fieldness from the Colombian case

Gutiérrez Ruan María, University of Lausanne

Lab-in-the-field experiments (LFEs) are situated between laboratory and field experiments, incorporating elements of both. Existing literature has mainly classified LFEs according to their research purposes. Building on Science and Technology Studies (STS), which have shown that the field can take different epistemological roles—as a site of experimentation, an object of study, and a site of intervention—this paper introduces the concept of fieldness to analyse how these roles operate within LFEs. Based on 14 semi-structured interviews with experimentalists and an analysis of their 36 publications stemming from the conduct of lab-in-the field experiments and discussed during the interviews, I advocate for an analysis of LFEs throughout three scales of fieldness. Scale 1 captures how closely the experimental design aligns with participants’ contextual realities. Scale 2 reflects the degree of engagement between experimentalists and participants through pre- and post-experiment dialogue. Scale 3 extends beyond the experimental setting, encompassing long-term collaborations and co-production processes between researchers and the communities involved. By distinguishing these scales, the paper shows that LFEs can be de-homogenised: rather than representing a single experimental type, they form a spectrum of approaches that differ in their modes of engagement with the field and in their proximity to it.

Area:

Keywords: Experimental economics; field experiments; Lab-in-the-field experiments; fieldwork