Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

Is emergy really a theory of value ? Emergy as a contested tool for development policies

Mosneron Dupin Hugo, ENS - CIRED

Although Odum is often viewed as a foundational figure in ecological economics, he is also widely regarded as the epitome of absolute energy reductionism and a strong proponent of an energetic theory of value. In this article, we challenge this view by discussing emergy analysis. We aim to enrich the epistemological and political reception of Odum's work to delve deeper into the philosophical issues raised by the articulation of ecology and economics. We argue that emergy is not as reductionist as commonly perceived. Emergy is neither constructed nor used as an energetic theory of value. Emergy appears as an environmental indicator that enables the construction of public development policies. Its development during the 1980s and 1990s can thus be analyzed in light of conflicts surrounding the notion of sustainable development. In particular, a divergence emerges between the interests of American organizations that funded its development and the results of the emergy analysis that Odum conducted on shrimp production in Ecuador. Moreover, it permits operationalizing the notion of ecologically unequal exchange, indicating that Odum's approach cannot be reduced merely to an engineering perspective focused on optimal environmental control. We begin with methodological considerations on the history of energy metrics in economics. We argue that a political history of this knowledge can shed light on many aspects of it. In the second part, we show that emergy is not constructed as a theory of value as it is neither a descriptive nor a normative theory of prices. To achieve this, we reconstruct the conceptual problems that give rise to this energy metric, compare it to other energy metrics, and then characterize it as a quantification of the metabolic dimension of the economy intended to inform political decision-making. In the third part, we demonstrate that emergy is not employed as a theory of value. To achieve this, we supplement the theoretical analysis of emergy by examining how Odum employs it in his consideration of development policies. To this end, we examine his report on intensive shrimp farming in Ecuador and the ecological-economic niche theory he deploys there. We show that Odum's conclusions are somewhat radical and divergent from what US-funded development policies would support. More precisely, Odum shows that development policies as they are usually implemented lead to a continued exploitation of these territories because they do not fit their metabolic profile (or ecological-economic niche). We can then deduce from Odum's reasoning an incremental conception of development that clashes with international organizations' and US government's conception. For Odum, the optimal development strategy is not to copy the behavior of the most developed countries and to maximize the integration of the local economy into international trade. On the contrary, these choices perpetuate economic and environmental exploitation. These clashes might explain why emergy analysis was abandoned during the 1990s, despite the substantial American funding Odum had received.

Area:

Keywords: development, ecological economics,theory of value, energy

Please Login in order to download this file