Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

Re-visiting Ambedkar’s Two Doctoral Theses: Investigating beyond Centre-State financial relationship, and gold-standard and gold-exchange standard

Chikoti Sai Sri Hari, University of Siena

The primary objective of the proposed paper is to shed light on Ambedkar’s writings with a new perspective. Dr. Babasaheb Ambedkar is the father of Indian Constitution and was trained in economics before he moved political science and other subdisciplines of law. This article engages with Ambedkar’s biography, his life at different institutions such as the Colombia University and the London School of Economics (LSE), themes in his writings—The problem of the rupee: its origin and its solution (1923), The evolution of provincial finance in British India (1925)—that were not discussed earlier in the literature. The article sheds lights on Ambedkar’s ideas in a thematic manner. It includes findings with respect to public spending, taxation, currency regimes, modes of administrations i.e., centralization and decentralization. Subsequently, the findings also prove that Ambedkar’s ideas and standpoints are not universal, but purely contextual in nature. In Indian economic thought, there is a lacuna with respect to Ambedkar's economics. Therefore, this paper undertakes a textual analysis of Ambedkar’s writings in the discipline of economics. The primary texts are The evolution of provincial finance in British India (1925) and The problem of the rupee: its origin and its solution (1923). Since the volume of literature vis-à-vis Ambedkar in economics is very little, these sections intend to act as a commentary explaining his standpoint with respect to various economic conditions, thematic realms and contexts that prevailed during the time of writing. There would be also be a dedicated section of this paper that attempts to grasp the nature of Indian economy in the time that Ambedkar was actively contributing to economics. Primarily, this section aims at understanding nationalist thinkers such as Ranade’s and Naoroji’s economics, and understanding the differences and similarities between their notions of economics and Ambedkar’s. The principal time period that this chapter engages with is 1890–1930 and economic conditions that prevailed at that time. The section on Ambedkar’s biography would provide insights into different institutions he studied at and the kind of people he was supervised by. Therefore, in one way, this article is also an attempt to highlight the importance of influences from the West on Indian thinkers and invites for innovative methodologies to study first generation thinkers from different contexts.

Area:

Keywords: Ambedkar, History of Indian Economics Thought, Gold Standard, Taxation, Centralisation & Decentralisation, Methodology