Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

[YSP] - Beyond markets – the notion of ‘social institution’ in the work of Arrow and Hurwicz.

Maayan Yam, Polonsky Academy, Van-Leer Jerusalem Institute

This paper challenges the prevailing view that post-war mathematical economics neglected the study of social institutions. According to the common narrative, the concept of institutions was largely abandoned after the decline of institutionalism, only to be revived decades later by the new institutionalism. This account, however, overlooks a central ambition of many post-war mathematical economists: to construct formal frameworks capable of analyzing the organization of society, including its institutional dimensions. Focusing on the intellectual trajectories of Kenneth Arrow and Leonid Hurwicz—two key figures in the development of general equilibrium theory—this paper traces how their engagement with formal modeling gave rise to distinct yet overlapping efforts to conceptualize institutions. Drawing on novel archival materials, the paper demonstrates the centrality of the notion of institutions in their work and characterizes their ambition: rather than studying concrete institutional forms empirically, they sought to formulate abstract structures that could encompass institutions for the purposes of mathematical analysis within a general equilibrium-inspired framework. By examining their work from their collaboration at the Cowles Commission onward, the paper highlights a broader project among post-war mathematical economists: extending economic analysis beyond the market model toward a wider class of institutionalized social interactions.

Area:

Keywords: post-war economics; mathematical economics; social institutions; general equilibrium theory; Kenneth Arrow; Leonid Hurwicz