The Academization of French Economic Expertise, 1945–2013
This article addresses the transformation of economic expertise in France since World War II: it shows the decline in pluralism of French economic expertise and its standardisation through the adoption of academic criteria. To trace the path of French economic expertise after 1945, I focus on the main institutions created by the French government to provide economic expertise and identify three stages. Until the end of 1970s, economic expertise was defined as a “state” monopoly, as economic information was produced by two administrations (the Direction de la Prévision and INSEE). These two institutions supplied economic and statistical information to the Commissariat général au plan (CGP), which brought together the administration, trade unionist representatives and employers to establish a consensus on economic guidelines – parliamentarians were mostly excluded from these decisions. In this configuration, economists had a limited role, primarily focused on producing economic information and ensuring the coherence of economic orientations. Their methods revolved around national accounting. However, the introduction of the mathematical models into administrative toolkit contributed in ushering in a new phase. The introduction of models transformed the role of economists. They began to make proposals for the direction of economic policy which provoked criticism from academics and economic columnists, and an opposition from unions representatives. In 1979, a report by René Lenoir and Baudoin Prot to the Prime Minister advocated for pluralist economic expertise, challenging the monopoly of the administration. Following their recommendations, Prime Minister Raymond Barre established three research institutes, each representing different stakeholders: employers (Rexecode), trade unions (Ires) and academics (OFCE). The pluralism of economic expertise was thus institutionally guaranteed, while at the same time the new role of economists, who were henceforth called upon to provide economic guidelines, was confirmed. This institutional pluralism configuration remained stable until the late 1990s. During the second phase, the interactions between economists and the political sphere was ensured by recruiting economists as advisers in the ministerial offices. In 1997, the Prime Minister, Lionel Jospin, reinforced this orientation by creating the Conseil d'analyse économique (CAE) to bring economic expertise closer to political power. Modelled after the German Der Sachverständigenrat zur Begutachtung der gesamtwirtschaftlichen Entwicklung and the American Council of Economic Advisers, this council was unique in that it convened a wide range of economists to foster political and scientific debate with the prime minister. Pluralism was ensured by a single institution that gathered the full spectrum of economists. After the 2008 financial crisis, it was argued that economists had missed the coming crisis because most of them had a conflict of interest with the financial sector. In 2012, the CAE transformed its composition to address this criticism by recruiting economists with high academic credentials – i.e. those who publish in Anglo-Saxon journals. As a result, the diversity of profiles within the institution decline, as has its pluralism.
Area:
Keywords: Economic Expertise, Postwar French economics
Il paper è coperto da copyright. The paper is copyrighted.