Reconsidering Marx’s Theory of Turnover under Uncertain Circulation: Japanese Marxian and Unoist Approaches
Marx investigated the turnover of capital in Chapter 15 of Volume II of Capital. Turnover comprises circulation in addition to production. Circulation realizes the value of commodities but also constrains production processes. Marx showed that this restriction can be overcome by advancing additional capital. Recent studies on Marx’s theory of turnover focus on the effects of turnover time on the periodic rate of profit and on the periodic appearance of money that is set free and remains idle for a time. However, these studies are confined to a deterministic view of both production and circulation and leave uncertainty in circulation unexplored. By contrast, this paper shifts the focus from deterministic processes in turnover to uncertainty in circulation and thereby reconsiders the concept of idle money. First, it shows that combining more than two production processes can eliminate set-free money, whereas Marx presupposed only two processes. This multiple-production method was proposed by Japanese Marxian economists as early as the 1940s. Second, the paper emphasizes the role of monetary reserves in addressing uncertainty in circulation time, rather than relying on the concept of set-free money. Under uncertainty, sales time may become shorter or longer at any given moment. Monetary reserves are therefore required to cope with uncertain circulation. Importantly, the appropriate level of monetary reserves cannot be determined objectively in advance, whereas the amount of set-free money is predetermined. Marx himself referred to uncertainty in sales as “salto mortale” and distinguished between monetary reserves and set-free money. Nevertheless, he often abstracted from uncertainty in circulation under the assumption of “normal business conditions”, in order to investigate the laws governing the production sphere. By contrast, Japanese Unoist scholars, who have reconstructed Capital logically following Kozo Uno, emphasize the importance of uncertainty in circulation. Building on this literature, the paper examines how uncertainty in circulation affects the turnover of capital. Third, the paper theoretically shows that uncertainty in circulation leads to a dispersion of idle money among industrial capitals. As a result, some capitals suffer from shortages of monetary reserves, while others hold excess idle money. Such excess money can be employed only in circulation for short periods, providing a theoretical foundation for the emergence of credit and other circulation-specialized activities. Thus, this paper contributes to the introduction of Japanese Marxian literature to the English-language debate and to the reexamination of Marx’s theory of turnover from the perspective of uncertainty in circulation.
Area:
Keywords: turnover of capital, idle money, uncertain circulation, Marxian economics, Unoist approach
Il paper è coperto da copyright. The paper is copyrighted.