Statistical Empiricism as Anti-Colonial Resistance: The Making of Indian Economic Thought
In late-nineteenth-century India, the colonial state determined which forms of economic argument could survive in print. This paper reconstructs the political topography of Indian nationalist economics, treating its methodological signatures as strategic adaptations to a regime of state filtering. Institutional constraints dictated individual choices: Dadabhai Naoroji wrote from London to secure a protected venue; Mahadev Govind Ranade used academic lectures because his judicial appointment foreclosed the press; Romesh Chunder Dutt delayed publication until retirement; Ganesh Venkatesh Joshi anonymously supplied data because the discipline of office silenced him. Outside these parameters, Bal Gangadhar Tilak deployed vernacular moralism and was imprisoned. The resulting environment permitted only two modes of critique: a statistical empiricism that turned imperial blue books against imperial narratives, and a historicism that weaponized the German Historical School against British classical doctrine. An alternative nationalist circuit carried these arguments outside the colonial university system, an institution built to reproduce orthodoxy rather than accommodate critique. The paper closes on a finding that travels beyond the case: the methodology that survived political pressure inherited the blind spots of the archive it accommodated. Because Naoroji and Dutt could indict the empire only within the categories the state chose to record, what went uncounted remained outside the critique, stalling the development of alternative conceptual tools. The Indian case thus demonstrates how political environments govern the methods that become canonical in the history of economic thought.
Area:
Keywords: History of Economic Thought, Political Economy of Colonialism, Methodology of Economics, Development Economics, Indian Nationalist Economics
Please Login in order to download this file