“Poverty Doctors” South of the Rio Grande: Transnational Expertise and the Design of Household Budget Surveys in Latin America
This paper examines the historical role of foreign consultants in shaping the development of household budget surveys across Latin America during the twentieth century. Drawing inspiration from the well-known literature on “Money Doctors”—economists from developed countries who travelled abroad to advise governments on monetary and financial reforms—this study proposes the concept of “Poverty Doctors” to describe a parallel but understudied group of overseas specialists who provided technical assistance on the design of household consumption and budget surveys. Whereas Money Doctors addressed problems of currency, credit, and monetary stability, Poverty Doctors intervened in domains related to living standards, subsistence, and social policy. Their work helped define how poverty, consumption, and the cost of living were statistically observed and represented in Latin America. The analysis builds on an extensive sources database of household budget surveys conducted across nineteen Latin American countries throughout the twentieth century. These include South America (excluding Guyana and Suriname), Central America, Cuba, and Mexico. These surveys were fundamental instruments for understanding the living conditions of the working population and for informing policies such as minimum wage legislation, social protection initiatives, and the construction of cost-of-living indices. In contexts where subsistence wages could not be assumed, the quality and methodological sophistication of these surveys were crucial for translating social conditions into statistical evidence. Within this landscape, foreign consultants played a notable—if dispersed and largely unexamined—role. The paper identifies several such individuals, including the German economist Paul Hermberg (in Colombia, 1936), the Austrian-American chemist Emma Reh (in Paraguay, 1943), and the Dutch-American economist Hendrik Houthakker (in Chile, 1965), among others. Although not part of a coordinated movement, these individuals shared a common position: they were either hired by governments or assigned by international organisations to assist in the creation or reform of household budget surveys, often labelled “poverty surveys” in the early twentieth century. Through their interventions, they transmitted methodological standards, shaped sampling strategies, and influenced how poverty and living conditions were conceptualised and measured. By reconstructing the activities, ideas, and institutional contexts of these Poverty Doctors, the paper contributes to a deeper understanding of the transnational construction of economic expertise in Latin America. It shows how statistical knowledge about poverty emerged from the interplay between domestic needs and foreign advisory work, thereby illuminating a neglected dimension of the region’s economic and social history.
Area:
Keywords: Latin America. Household Budget Surveys. Economic Experts.
Please Login in order to download this file