Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

[YSP] Modeling the World Economy: Guy Orcutt and the Forgotten Origins of Economic Research at the World Bank

Hošman Mirek Tobiáš, Einaudi Foundation & European University Institute

The World Bank is one of the most important centers of economic research worldwide. With financial resources, data infrastructures, and analytical capacities comparable to leading academic departments, it has occupied a distinctive position at the intersection of scholarship, policy, and international governance. Often described as a “Knowledge Bank”, the institution has become a central site for the production of economic expertise that shapes both development practice and global economic debates. Despite this prominence, historical understanding of the origins and trajectory of the Bank research program remains limited. The conventional narrative usually locates the emergence of centralized economic research in the presidency of Robert McNamara (1968–81), emphasizing the role of Chief Economist Hollis Chenery as the principal architect of the Bank’s research apparatus formally institutionalized in 1971. However, this paper – part of the ERC project ECOINT – revisits an earlier, mostly forgotten episode: an attempt to establish a research function at the World Bank in the late 1960s under the leadership of economist Guy Orcutt. A renowned econometrician, Distinguished Fellow of the American Economic Association, and key contributor to the development of economic statistics and econometrics, Orcutt was invited by Chenery’s predecessor, chief economist Irving Friedman, to join the World Bank and articulate what kind of research the organization should pursue and how it might assert intellectual leadership in the development field. Yet his brief engagement with the Bank remains absent from institutional histories, the historiography of economic research, and the scholarship on Orcutt’s intellectual contributions. Based on new archival sources, this paper reconstructs Orcutt’s proposal to establish a central research function at the Bank together with the intellectual debates surrounding it. It traces disagreements over the purpose of a research function, the nature of economic inquiry, and the promises and limits of quantitative and model-based analysis at the Bank. At the same time, it highlights the administrative and organizational challenges underlying the possibilities of conducting research within an operational lending institution with a complex financial, political, and diplomatic mandate. In line with the analytical approach that focuses on internal lives of international organizations and the role of individuals working within them, I show how economists tasked with designing a research program at the World Bank themselves perceived the rationale, scope, intended audience, and mission of what they were trying to achieve. Their debates reveal the original reasons for establishing a research function, themes identified as important, and arguments mobilized to support different viewpoints. The paper also highlights an important episode in the history of development economics. The debates triggered by Orcutt’s report, as well as the subsequent institutional developments, capture the period of rupture and the contingent emergence of a new intellectual climate – shaped externally by wider disciplinary shifts and internally by the ascending McNamara’s regime. This was exemplified by the limited resources and consideration that Orcutt’s project received – prompting his early departure from the Bank – only for a similar conception to flourish a few years later. Orcutt’s brief engagement with the Bank thus offers a new perspective on how the institution transformed from a cautious lender with minimal research capacity and little interest in economic analysis into one of the world’s most important intellectual actors in development economics. ECOINT: This paper has received funding from the European Research Council (ERC) under the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation program (grant agreement No 885285)

Area:

Keywords: World Bank – Economic Research – Development Economics – Econometrics – Guy Orcutt

Please Login in order to download this file