Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

[YSP] Thomas Aquinas, William Petty, and the Shift in the Conceptualisation of Labour from the Middle Ages to Early Capitalism

Kritsotakis Spiros, National and Kapodistrian University of Athens

Labour has long occupied a central position in economic theory, while the intellectual approaches towards it have been influenced by the development of socioeconomic conditions. From the history of economic thought perspective, labour has mainly been studied in the context of the labour theory of value, while the ontological and ethical position of the economists towards labour and the labourer remain mostly unstudied. This paper addresses this unexplored dimension for the scholastic and mercantilist era by contrasting the works of two prominent figures of this literature, St Thomas Aquinas and Sir William Petty. By grounding their views in a historically sensitive perspective by identifying the specific elements of feudalism and early capitalism which shaped their approach towards labour, along with the socioeconomic shifts of their respective era, this study explores the evolution of the conceptualisation of labour. While Thomas Aquinas understood the importance of human labour for the existence of society and attempted to morally justify and integrate the activities of the emerging merchant class under Christian dogma and Aristotelian ethics, Petty represents a theoretical reorientation. Moving away from the moral justifications of the scholastics, he recognised human labour not only as fundamental for existence but also for the welfare of society by connecting the amount of labour with the State’s prosperity and focusing on quantitative aspects. The paper concludes that the 16th and 17th centuries mark a fundamental effort to decouple labour from divine teleology, which has been the case since the 11th century and reconsider it as a more practical instrument which can be scientifically studied. This transition was driven by the degree of development of commerce, which required a different approach towards labour and the labourer.

Area:

Keywords: History of Econmic Thought; Labour; Thomas Aquinas; William Petty; Scholasticism; Mercantilism

Please Login in order to download this file