Resituating Neoliberal Theory Within the Liberal Tradition
Over the last decades, scholars often relied on the concept of neoliberalism to explain the contemporary political and economic crises. Importantly, many theorists maintained that the problems created by neoliberalism in practice can be traced back to neoliberal thought. As a result, they have directed their attention to neoliberal theorists, from Friedrich Hayek to Milton Friedman to the German ordoliberals, which they have subjected to detailed studies and critiques. However, some scholars argue that the authors gathered under the label “neoliberalism” are too heterogenous to constitute a coherent movement of thought. In particular, these authors have suggested that neoliberal theory as it was developed in the 1930s is irreconcilable with what neoliberalism came to signify in the 1970s. The heterogeneity within neoliberal thought is such that the boundaries between neoliberal theory and other liberal currents are contested. For instance, Friedrich Hayek is sometimes depicted as a Cold War liberal or libertarian rather than as a neoliberal thinker. Therefore, it remains unclear whether the term “neoliberalism” can be meaningfully used to characterize a distinct body of thought, and, to extent that it could, what would be its place within the liberal tradition. This contribution intervenes in these debates in two ways: (1) by discussing the homogeneity of neoliberal theory across time, and (2) by resituating neoliberalism within 20th century liberalism. First, while some scholars argue that 1930s neoliberalism radically differs from 1970s neoliberalism, I argue that this contrast is exaggerated. What neoliberals share, above all, is a belief in the sanctity of the price mechanism, and a common endeavor to find the best way to sanctify it through the ‘right’ institutions and social norms. This assessment immediately raises the question: is that enough to make it a distinct body of thought? This paper argues that this is the case because this common denominator distinguishes neoliberal theory from the other three great liberal renewals in the 20th century, i.e. social liberalism (e.g. John Dewey, Leonard Hobhouse), Cold War liberalism (e.g. Raymond Aron, Isaiah Berlin), and libertarianism (e.g. Murray Rothbard). Overall, this paper shows that neoliberal thought represents a specific renewal of liberalism in the 20th century and that it thereby constitutes a distinct and coherent variant of liberal political philosophy.
Area:
Keywords: Neoliberalism; social liberalism; libertarianism; Cold War liberalism; Hayek; Friedman; Röpke; 20th century liberal thought; political economy
Il paper è coperto da copyright. The paper is copyrighted.