Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

Why did Early Modern China persist in Physiocracy?

Zhao Xuan, Shanghai University of Finance and Economics

While most European countries in the seventeenth and eighteenth century emulated each other in adopting the mercantilist policies to promote the capitalistic manufacturing industries and the long-range maritime shipping, contemporaneous China persisted in the physiocratic policies to maintain a traditional agrarian economy. This divergence in political economy and state policy had profound practical influence, as the mercantilist policies catalyzed the modern industrial capitalism and drove European economies to the development path of increasing returns and the physiocratic policies pushed traditional China to the deadend of decreasing returns and involution. However, it seemed that there existed inducements and chances for early modern China to be not as physiocratic as it actually was in history. Moreover, within the state leadership and intellectuals, the suggestions were also made about promoting manufacturing and avoiding physiocracy. However, the official economic ideology of early modern China was so rigid that nearly all those inducements, chances and suggestions were neglected and the physiocracy was persisted in. This article tries to explore the reasons behind such persistence of the official economic ideology of early modern China, the orthodox Confucianism, in physiocracy. And preliminarily, this article finds that such persistence in physiocracy was caused by an ideological and institutional factor: the sanctification of "benevolent policy" in Confucianism. According to Confucian state theory, to practice the "benevolent policy" was the chief legitimacy to rule the country, and emperor and ministers would risk their legitimacy if they violated the principles of the "benevolent policy". Confucian "benevolent policy" requested the adoption of at least three following principles: reducing taxation, idealizing small peasant economy, and welcoming "lassiez faire". To conform with these three principles could lead to the persistency in Physiocracy. This article discusses how keeping in alignment with the "benevolent policy" which was the legitimacy of the imperial Chinese state could restrict early modern Chinese state leadership to devise the effective solution to break away from the path of decreasing returns and remain persistent in Physiocracy, although the inducement and chances for taking the path of increasing returns probably existed in early modern China.

Area:

Keywords: Confucianism, Benevolent Policy, Decreasing Returns, Great Divergence

Please Login in order to download this file