Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

Pedagogy for Whom? The case of the 3-equation New Keynesian Model

Aurélien Saïdi, ENS Paris-Saclay
Cherrier Beatrice, CREST, CNRS

This paper challenges the conventional separation between "pedagogical" (classroom) applications of economic models and their "scientific" uses in academic discourse. We demonstrate this blurred boundary through a case study of the 3-equation New Keynesian model, which emerged when central bank researchers reconstructed the IS-LM-PC framework to incorporate expectations and reflect the shift toward inflation targeting in monetary policy. Notably, the same macroeconomists deployed this policy evaluation framework both as evidence of a new scientific consensus and as an instructional tool. Across these diverse spheres—from policy modeling to academic publications to teaching—discussion of what made the 3-equation model a "good" one consistently referenced the same epistemic virtues: simplicity, realism, consistency, and less tangible qualities like "straightforwardness" and "intuition building," which ultimately reflect the persuasiveness of the model's narratives.

Area:

Keywords: 3-Equation Model, Pedagogy, Classroom, Central Banks, Academia

Please Login in order to download this file