One Century of Economic History
We analyze all the 5000+ papers published in the Economic History Review and the Journal of Economic History between 1927 and 2025 to evaluate how the discipline of economic history has evolved over the last century. For each article, in addition to metrics such as gender and institutional affiliation of the authors, we classify the research area, historical periods, geographic region of the study, the use of quantitative methods and provide a two sentences abstract. With this new database, we show how the structure, methods and periods of these studies have changed over time. The early themes of both journals were often closely tied to their geographical focus. The Economic History Review devoted considerable attention to European issues, particularly those of Britain, covering topics such as the Industrial Revolution, agrarian history, and the London financial market. In contrast, the Journal of Economic History served as an important forum for the economic history of the United States, addressing topics such as slavery, westward expansion, industrial development, and labor market history. But from the 1960s and 1970s onward, there was a marked convergence of topics, which accelerated during the 1980s and 1990s. The scope of both journals has increasingly overlapped, with each now covering a broad range of historical economic issues from around the world. We suggest that this convergence reflects the standardization of graduate training, the consolidation of scholarly associations, and the cliometric revolution’s establishment of a shared methodological framework. At the same time, the journals have increasingly engaged with issues of contemporary relevance, including inequality, gender and race, environmental change, migration, corporate governance, and financial crises. This also allows us to analyze the evolution of the history of economic thought prior to its institutionalization in the 1970s with the creation of specialized journals. Studies in the history of economic thought tended to link economic ideas directly to historical events and public policies, for instance by examining how the ideas of specific authors influenced government practice or how historical events shaped the thinking of economic theorists. These works generally employed a more narrative and biographical methodology, and although much of the scholarship focused on major figures such as Adam Smith and David Ricardo, there was already an effort to recover and reassess lesser-known authors. We conjecture that the separation from economic history may have led the history of economic thought to become a more internalist field.
Area:
Keywords: Disciplinary evolution; Economic History; Bibliometric.
Please Login in order to download this file