The birth and diffusion of "orthodox" in economics
“Orthodox economics” is a ubiquitous concept. Yet, the label itself has seldom been reflected upon. Contrary to other labels in the history of economic thought, which have a clear and well-documented origin, the origins of the term “orthodox” in economics have never been systematically investigated, even though several articles have attempted to delineate the doctrinal content associated with it. The purpose of this paper is to understand how and when the words “orthodox” and “orthodoxy” were introduced into economics. We ask a simple yet fascinating question: in what contexts, and under what conditions, have some economists referred to others—or to themselves—as “orthodox” economists? The paper first argues that studying how economists name others or are themselves named is of interest to the history of economic thought, as it reveals underlying tensions and affinities. Naming can serve both to praise and to criticize, to signal belonging to a group, or, conversely, to mark exclusion from it. These processes are then illustrated by tracking the use of “orthodox” in large corpora of texts in English, French, German, and, more marginally, Italian, from the beginning to the end of the nineteenth century. We show that the term “orthodox” has a distinctly French origin, dating back to the early 1840s. It appears to have been common parlance within the Société d’économie politique, a group of French political economists following the tradition of Jean-Baptiste Say. This was a time when these political economists were facing increasing criticism and competition from Saint-Simonians. Referring to an orthodoxy was a means of closing ranks and strengthening the unity of political economy. By recording the discursive context of each occurrence, we show how the intended meaning and effect of referring to an “orthodox” position evolved over the decades, oscillating between reward, sarcasm and neutral description. At the turn of the 1870s, when traditional political economy was challenged by various thinkers of a more institutionalist bend, the somewhat forgotten Belgian economist Émile de Laveleye used “orthodox” to describe the position under contestation. His intervention for the centenary of the publication of The Wealth of Nations spread the term in the Anglophone world. We conclude by examining what the history of a key term in economics reveals about the discipline itself and its relationship to other intellectual pursuits.
Area:
Keywords: orthodoxy, political economy, XIXth century
Please Login in order to download this file