Pre-Qin Confucianism and laissez-faire: deconstructing the myth
The seminal laissez-faire interpretation of ancient Confucian thought by a Chinese author was advanced by Chen Huanzhang in his The Economic Principles of Confucius and His School (1911). Beginning in the late 1980s, the interpretation was revived in China. Although this occurred independently of any acknowledged influence from Chen’s study, which was only translated into Chinese in 2009, the evidence adduced in favour of the interpretation was exactly the same. As I argue, this evidence is, and always was, manifestly inadequate to support the laissez-faire attribution. I begin by reviewing the “economic” contributions of the three major pre-Qin Confucian thinkers -Confucius, Mencius and Xunzi- each located in their historical context and, for purposes of comparison, with attention to the “Legalist” doctrine that came to dominate the “Warring States Period” of the two later Confucians. I then turn to the context in which the laissez-faire interpretations were advanced. In Chen’s case, the interpretation was designed to provide Confucian support for a programme of economic reform first articulated by Chen’s mentor, Kang Youwei, at the end of the nineteenth century. The later interpretations gained currency in the context of the post-Mao period in China which, following the rabid anti-Confucian campaign that had been waged during the “Great Proletarian Cultural Revolution”, witnessed a “New Confucian Revival” alongside the instigation of economic reforms under the banner of promoting “socialism with Chinese characteristics”. Several Chinese historians of economic thought participated in the discussions that followed, with some suggesting that the laissez-faire (or “free market”) position allegedly espoused by pre-Qin Confucians was relevant to understanding contemporary developments, and to the furtherance of reformist ambitions. However, it became clear that the ultimate goal differed radically from Chen Huanzhang’s and Kang Youwei’s. Yet, despite this difference, there was one thing in common: earlier and later proponents of the laissez-faire interpretation were disseminating the same blatant myth.
Area:
Keywords: Kang Youwei, Chen Huanzhang, Confucius
Please Login in order to download this file