Unequal exchange: the key to understanding the schism within World-system theory (1977–2005)
At the origin of the theoretical disagreements observed within dependency theory community, the debate over the terms of trade—and thus over the inequality of commercial exchanges between the center and the periphery—was a key factor behind the fragmentation of this intellectual community in the 1990s. From their perspective, these thinkers viewed international exchanges as the primary cause of the continued dependence of the periphery on the center (Katz 2022). The dissensions generated by the debate on unequal exchange, extending beyond mere analytical concerns, provided the basis for a rupture within this community grounded in political disagreements regarding how to resolve the problem of underdevelopment. The main protagonists of this debate were Samir Amin (1931–2018) and Andre Gunder Frank (1929–2005). This article explores how this debate unfolded within this neo-Marxist–inspired intellectual community. The debate is marked by rich internal disagreements, which largely stem from differences in their respective intellectual influences. I thus show that while Amin adopted Arghiri Emmanuel’s Marxist conception of unequal exchange, Frank, for his part, drew on his exchanges with Ernest Mandel to produce a Trotskyist reading of unequal exchange without adopting its conceptual content (Emmanuel 1969; Mandel 1976; Frank 1977; Amin 1987). These differing perspectives, which are based on contrasting interpretations of the functioning of the global rate of profit, led Amin and Frank to distinct views of international trade. In particular, Amin, drawing on his analysis of unequal exchange, advocates the delinking of the periphery from international trade, whereas Frank does not consider this solution sufficient to counteract the inequality inherent in such exchanges (Frank 1977; Amin 1985; CODESRIA 2022). Bibliography: Amin, Samir. 1985. La deconnexion / pour sortir du systeme mondial. [1986]. La Découverte. Amin, Samir. 1987. L’échange inégal et la loi de la valeur. FeniXX réédition numérique. CODESRIA. 2022. Pr. Samir Amin (1973-1975) – CODESRIA. https://codesria.org/fr/pr-samir-amin-1973-1975/. Emmanuel, Arghiri. 1969. L’échange inégal : essai sur les antagonismes dans les rapports économiques internationaux. Éd. revue et complétée édition. With Charles Bettelheim. F. Maspero. Frank, Andre Gunder. 1977. L’Accumulation mondiale, 1500-1800. Translated by Catherine Gajdos. Calmann-Lévy. Katz, Claudio. 2022. “Dependency Theory After Fifty Years: The Continuing Relevance of Latin American Critical Thought.” In Dependency Theory After Fifty Years. Brill. https://brill.com/display/title/60920. Mandel, Ernest. 1976. Le Troisième Âge Du Capitalisme, t.2. 10 18.
Area:
Keywords: dependency theory, unequal exchange, marxism, Samir Amin, Andre Gunder Frank, delinking
Please Login in order to download this file