Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

Edmund Burke’s political economy in the aftermath of the Seven Years’ War: public debt in modern states

Shiozawa Kohei, University of St Andrews

As the scholarship on Burke’s economic thought has developed, it has become clear that he is not a mere disciple of Adam Smith as he has once been viewed not least because of their disagreement about primogeniture and entail (Winch 1985). Instead, commentators have identified his stark criticism of the political instability posed by monied interest in the context of the French Revolution and his characteristically healthy confidence in Britain’s economic prospects grounded on the balanced relationship between landed and monied interest (Pocock 1982; Canavan 1995; Collins 2020). It is often further suggested that this optimistic understanding of Britain’s economic structure had already taken shape at an early stage of his career, long before the Revolution. In this guise, the intellectual background in which Burke developed his optimistic faith in public debt and Britain's sound ability to utilise it remains underexplored. This paper addresses this gap by examining Burke’s engagement with the comparative debates on the economic stability of Britain and France in the aftermath of the Seven Years’ War. It traces the trajectory from his early historical writings to his first extended publication after entering Parliament, Observations on a Late State of the Nation (1769), written to vindicate the Rockingham ministry. Taken together, these texts reveal his clear analysis of the economic structure of both nations and the critical effects of the cumulative public debt especially in France. By situating Burke’s analysis within the broader climate of pessimism that pervaded British political discourse after the Seven Years’ War, this paper argues that Burke occupied a distinctive intellectual position: he was free from both the moral pessimism that lamented the decay of public spirits in commercial society and the political pessimism that prophesied the death of economy as an inevitable result of public debt. Rather, Burke was more ready to accept public debt as a means to sustain national glory, insomuch as other systems such as commerce, manufacturing, and public credit worked well in tandem with it. It was this realistic standpoint that laid the foundation for later Burke’s political economy.

Area:

Keywords: Edmund Burke, Seven Years' War, public debt

Please Login in order to download this file