Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

Historians of Economics and Neoliberalism: A Chronicle of Ignorance

Giraud Yann, CY Cergy Paris Université

Since the publication in 2004 (and in English in 2008) of Michel Foucault’s lectures at the Collège de France, studies of neoliberalism have quite literally exploded in the academic world. A simple search using Google Books’ N-Gram Viewer confirms that this enthusiasm shows no sign of waning: the terms “neoliberal” and “neoliberalism” now appear far more frequently than, for example, “fascism” or “fascist.” The plasticity of the concept—its capacity to denote a wide range of ideas, policies, and social practices—undoubtedly helps to explain this proliferation. Nevertheless, engagement with this literature reveals the extent to which, despite the methodological and semantic difficulties involved in mobilizing such a multifaceted notion, it has helped illuminate the ways in which economic concepts have been deployed as technologies of governance at the intersection of science, politics, and activism. The success of this body of work has been such that, in the public imagination, as well as within parts of the academic world, economics as a field of knowledge has come to be viewed as almost synonymous with neoliberal thought alone. This situation stands in stark contrast to the near absence of neoliberalism as a category in the literature on the history of economic thought—at least as this field is practiced and defined by its principal learned societies and scholarly journals. With a few notable exceptions—such as the work of Philip Mirowski and his followers, which now belongs as much to critical studies as to the history of economics proper—most contributions in this field that mention neoliberalism do so either to criticize the concept itself or to lament what they see as its misrepresentation of economic knowledge. Conversely, the majority of historical studies devoted to key figures commonly associated with neoliberalism (Hayek, Mises, Buchanan, among others) make a deliberate effort to avoid the term altogether. In this historiographical intervention, I seek to trace the respective trajectories of these literatures and to examine their points of contact — or, more often, their mutual indifference. I argue that this disconnect reflects an ongoing identity crisis within the community of historians of economic thought, marked by a limited engagement with intellectual and social history and, as a consequence, by an insufficient understanding of the concrete mechanisms through which economic ideas circulate and acquire influence in political and public arenas.

Area:

Keywords: Neoliberalism; Historiography; Agnotology; Intellectual History; Critical Theory

Please Login in order to download this file