Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

Economists and Death Penalty in the 1970s

Fleury Jean-baptiste, Sorbonne Universtié

This paper seeks to contextualize the work of and debates among economists on death penalty in the 1970s. The most important contribution in that period is undoubtedly Isaac Ehrlich’s econometric studies of the deterrent effect of death penalty. This work illustrated the peculiar angle through which economists chose to address the matter at the time: it was, in a way, a continuation of Gary Becker’s ground braking work on the economics of crime a few years earlier. Although Ehrlich himself claim that his work came from a different set of questions than those of Becker’s, our attempt to explore the intellectual and historical context reveals a strong Chicago connection. Indeed, Ehrlich’s early studies were immediately publicized during a very important Supreme Court Case, as it was cited in an amicus brief co-authored Robert Bork and Frank Easterbrook. Interestingly, the influence of research on capital punishment appears ambiguous. On the one hand, it was portrayed as playing some part in the Supreme Court’s decision to end the moratorium on death penalty in the second half of the 1970s. Yet, the host of methodological criticisms it gathered made economic proofs of the deterrent effect eventually lose part of its credibility and influence. Indeed, Ehrlich’s work would be immediately and intensely debated by legal scholars, but by economists as well, in particular Lawrence Klein. We will try to understand how the debates took place but also to address the political aspects of the debates, as it seems clear that economists’ take on death penalty was immediately taken outside of academia, to feed an intense political and judicial debate, at a very specific time in US history, when something close to the abolition of death penalty appeared as a possibility.

Area:

Keywords: Economics of Crime, microeconomics, Chicago school, Becker