A Critical Analysis of First-Generation Indian PhD Theses Inspired by Sraffa
The present work examines three first-generation Indian PhD theses (later published as books) inspired by Sraffa’s book, the revival of Classical Political economy and the Cambridge capital controversies. Given the milieu of the times – debates on economic planning, underdevelopment, the role of the markets, and the critique and search for an alternate theoretical framework that would challenge the dominance of neoclassical economics. Gautam Mathur (1962), Kamala Subramaniam (1987), and Sudhanshu Bhushan (1996) explored these themes in their respective works. From Mathur developing planning models of growth based on the Sraffa-Neumann process and Keynesian macro-dynamics avoiding capital theoretic problems and bringing out the interdependent nature of production, to Kamala (Mathur’s student) working out the implications of multiple-switching in capital theory to Bhushan’s assessment of Classical Political Economy as a superior methodologically and theoretical alternative to the neoclassical system. In these works, one can sense the inspiration from Sraffa and other related works on capital theory and Post Keynesianism. These first generations of theses had an enthusiasm and eagerness to enhance and see through a complete critique of neoclassical economics on the one hand and to develop a different theoretical approach to the problems of underdevelopment. However, their research agenda and enthusiasm were not fully realized by subsequent generations of Indian scholars, primarily due to institutional factors, among other reasons.
Area:
Keywords: Indian EconomicThought; Sraffa; Classical Political Economy; Capital Theory
Please Login in order to download this file