Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

[YSP] Schumpeter on the “Woman Question” in the United States and Austria, 1913-1916

Sasaki Nozomi, The University of Tokyo

The 1910s witnessed a global intensification of women's movements, accompanied by growing debates among contemporary economists over the changing social and economic roles of women. Joseph Alois Schumpeter (1883–1950) was no exception, participating in discussions of women's suffrage and women's access to higher education during his time in both the United States and Austria. He has been characterized as relatively progressive among early twentieth-century male economists, largely on the basis of newspaper articles written during his 1913–1914 stay in the United States that appeared to endorse women's suffrage. Within the specific milieu of Columbia University—where support for suffrage was prominent among his academic interlocutors—his favorable stance toward women's enfranchisement aligns with a group of relatively egalitarian American economists. However, a different picture emerges when his views are examined alongside his 1916 Austrian newspaper article on women's legal education. While Schumpeter supported the admission of women to law faculties, he explicitly sought to exclude them from legal professions, aligning himself with moderate Austrian reformers who viewed education as an economic necessity rather than a pathway to professional equality. By comparing these American and Austrian discourses—published in newspaper articles largely neglected in the secondary literature—this paper argues that Schumpeter's engagement with women's rights was not driven by egalitarian ideals, but functioned as an adaptation to preserve the bourgeois social order in response to modern economic pressures. His arguments did not challenge the prevailing sexual division of labor; rather, they framed women's inclusion as a pragmatic adjustment to reconcile modern economic pressures with the foundations of bourgeois life. This analysis reveals that Schumpeter's claim to analytical neutrality concealed normative commitments rooted in the gendered presuppositions of his theoretical framework—the assumption that the bourgeois male breadwinner household constitutes the foundation of entrepreneurial motivation and social order.

Area:

Keywords: Schumpeter, Feminism, Women’s Suffrage and Higher Education

Please Login in order to download this file