Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

Miguel de Unamuno’s Political Economy

Ortega José Antonio, Universidad de Salamanca

Miguel de Unamuno (1864-1936), though globally recognized as an existential philosopher and man of letters, maintained a profound and consistent engagement with political economy, a field he considered—alongside religion—as one of the "two hinges of human history". This study analyzes Unamuno’s economic thought as it was forged under the pressures of the 1890 industrial strikes in Biscay, the 1898 national disaster, and the chronic agrarian crisis of Castile, and contained in several hundred papers on economic issues stemming from a personal reading from classical economists to socialism, from Henry George to Jevons or the German historical school. While the socialist and political writings of Unamuno are well studied, this is the first overview of Unamuno’s economic writings. Unamuno’s economic framework was deeply influenced by the Italian school, particularly the works of Achille Loria and Francesco Nitti. Adopting Loria’s "free land" theory, Unamuno argued that capitalism and coerced labor are historical consequences of land monopoly. He applied this logic to his "conquest of the mesetas," where he denounced "emigrating" landowners—large latifundistas who prioritized maximizing rent through extensive cattle farming over the sustenance of human populations, effectively "eating" the peasantry to sustain their urban luxuries. In the realm of labor, Unamuno developed a sophisticated theory of strikes, viewing them as a bargaining process necessary to reveal the maximum wage a capitalist could pay without abandoning their industry. Influenced by Nitti, he championed the "economy of high wages," positing that labor pressure is the true motor of technical innovation. He argued that only when labor becomes expensive are capitalists "forced to be inventors" and adopt machinery. But, most of all, he liked to deal with a variety of topics, from monetary theory to economic cycles, from the paradox of value to effective demand. Methodologically, Unamuno performed a radical critique of the homo oeconomicus of classical economics, dismissing it as a "non-man" and an abstract "idea". Instead, he proposed an economic science centered on the "man of flesh and bone". Finally, this study documents Unamuno’s evolution from a personal brand of socialism in the 1890s to a critical skepticism in his later years. He eventually questioned whether a collective organization could truly replace the individual function of "innovation and risk". Ultimately, following John Ruskin, Unamuno concluded that "there is no wealth but life," and that the goal of political economy must be the production of “noble and happy human beings”. This research highlights Unamuno as a significant, if overlooked, figure in the history of economic thought who sought to reconcile the "efficient cause" of economics with the "final cause" of the human spirit.

Area:

Keywords: Miguel de Unamuno - High-wage theory - Agrarian Reform - Socialism.

Il paper è coperto da copyright. The paper is copyrighted.