Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

Schumpeter and Keynes on International Economy: Implications for Protectionism

KOBAYASHI Daisuke, Asahikawa City University

This study explores the contrasting visions of Joseph A. Schumpeter and John M. Keynes regarding capitalism and the international economic order during the interwar period, highlighting their responses to crises and the implications for contemporary protectionism. It draws on a textual analysis of their major works, including Keynes’s The Economic Consequences of the Peace (1919) and Schumpeter’s The Sociology of Imperialism (1919), to clarify the methodological and normative foundations of their positions.   Both economists initially endorsed liberal trade and pacifism as foundations for peace, yet their trajectories diverged sharply after World War I. Keynes, disillusioned by punitive reparations and economic instability, criticized the Versailles Treaty in The Economic Consequences of the Peace and gradually shifted toward protectionism and domestically oriented demand management. His later writings, including “National Self-Sufficiency” (1933), reflect a practical turn toward economic nationalism, emphasizing capital controls and selective tariffs to safeguard employment and social stability. Keynes viewed policy as an instrument for welfare, prioritizing short-term remedies over doctrinaire liberalism.   Conversely, Schumpeter remained commitment to free trade principles and the dynamic efficiency of competitive markets. Rooted in Austrian theoretical traditions, he argued that imperialism and protectionism were vestiges of pre-capitalist structures, incompatible with rational capitalist development in his “The Sociology of Imperialism.” Even during the Great Depression, Schumpeter resisted interventionist policies, framing downturns as cyclical phenomena and insisting that “creative destruction” was the engine of progress. His critique of neo-Marxist imperialism theories underscored his belief that capitalism fosters peace through rationalization and international division of labor.   The paper identifies three fundamental differences: methodological orientation (Schumpeter’s abstract theoretical analysis versus Keynes’s policy-driven reasoning), their visions of capitalism (Schumpeter’s faith in long-term innovation versus Keynes’s concern over declining investment efficiency), and their views on the economist’s role (predictive rationality embedded in long-run theoretical visions versus active intervention under an intentionally restricted scope). By situating these debates within the broader context of rising economic nationalism, the study argues that effective crisis responses require substantive ideological foundations. Keynes’s inward-looking policies could risk degenerating into populist slogans without enlightened self-interest, while Schumpeter’s defense of liberal trade demands a resilient conceptual base to withstand political pressures.   Ultimately, both thinkers sought peace and prosperity, yet their contrasting prescriptions—state-led adaptation versus market autonomy—continue to resonate amid today’s resurgence of protectionism. This historical comparison offers a framework for reassessing globalization, economic nationalism, and the ethical underpinnings of liberalism in an era of uncertainty.

Area:

Keywords: Schumpeter, Keynes, Autarkism, Protectionism, Cobdenism.

Please Login in order to download this file