The Political Limits of Economic Expertise in Late Francoism
This paper examines how a group of economists linked to the Research Service of the Bank of Spain articulated a sustained critique of the Franco regime’s economic policies in the final years of the dictatorship, and where the political limits of such criticism ultimately lay. The origins of this critical stance can be traced back to the transformation of the Bank of Spain’s Research Service initiated in the late 1950s with the arrival of Joan Sardà. Under his leadership, and later under the direction of his successor, Ángel Madroñero, the Service incorporated new analytical tools, drew on international central banking practices, and consolidated a professional culture centered on macroeconomic coherence, monetary stability, and empirical rigor. While this expertise initially contributed to the design of the 1959 Stabilization Plan, it also enabled increasingly explicit diagnoses of the structural weaknesses of the regime’s economic governance. By the late 1960s, a younger generation of economists—many trained abroad and recruited through newly established competitive examinations—extended this critical perspective. Their analyses first circulated through internal memoranda and technical reports and, more visibly, through the Bank of Spain’s Annual Report, which became a key space for cautious but pointed criticism of economic policy. Over time, however, these economists sought to project their assessments beyond the institutional framework of the central bank. Taking advantage of the partial liberalization of the press following the 1966 Press Law, they collectively acquired the long-established journal "España Económica", transforming it into a platform for more explicit and sustained debate. Through the journal, they criticized the lack of coordination among policymaking bodies, the absence of effective central bank autonomy, the clientelistic allocation of official credit, the persistence of monopolistic structures, the regressive tax system, and the social and territorial imbalances generated by development policies. Although framed in technical language, these arguments carried clear normative implications that implicitly challenged core features of authoritarian rule. The administrative closure of "España Económica" in 1971 ultimately marked the threshold at which expert economic critique became politically intolerable, revealing both the possibilities and the limits of economic dissent under late Francoism.
Area:
Keywords: Economic thought, Francoist Spain, Central bank autonomy, Economic criticism, Press and censorship
Please Login in order to download this file