Garegnani on Surrogate Capital
This paper retraces the intellectual and historical path that led Pierangelo Garegnani to his most influential contribution to capital theory: “Heterogeneous Capital, the Production Function and the Theory of Distribution” (1970). Drawing on unpublished archival material from the Garegnani Archive, we reconstruct the origins of his critique of Samuelson’s “surrogate production function” and place it within the broader Cambridge capital controversies. The analysis focuses on Garegnani’s stay at MIT in 1961–62 as a Rockefeller Fellow, when he closely engaged with Samuelson’s work on capital theory. Early drafts and correspondence reveal that Garegnani had already identified the crucial theoretical weakness of the surrogate approach: the possibility of reswitching, or multiple crossings of factor-price frontiers, which undermines any invariant measure of capital. The paper further reconstructs the complex editorial history of Garegnani’s contribution to the Review of Economic Studies, highlighting the transformation of the manuscript through three distinct versions and the role played by changes in the journal’s editorial orientation. Overall, the paper sheds new light on the development of one of the most significant critiques of marginalist capital theory.
Area:
Keywords: Garegnani; Samuelson; capital; production function
Please Login in order to download this file