Ricardo’s Change of Mind about Machinery: Why the Mystery?
The reason for Ricardo’s change in position in the third edition of his Principles (1821) on the effects from the introduction if machinery is a question that continues to attract attention, recently from two Nobel-prize winning economists who argue that the change was likely prompted by the observed impact of automation in the cotton industry (Acemoglu and Johnson 2024). Other suggestions that continue to circulate include the influence of John Barton, and Ricardo’s attempt to correct what was perceived by him (wrongly) as Malthus’s misinterpretation of his chapter “On Gross and Net Revenue”. However, the real mystery is not so much the stimulus for the change as the doubt that continues to surround it. As I argue, it seems evident that the change was prompted not by external events, or Barton’s influence, but by Ricardo’s reading of one passage in the first edition of Malthus’s Principles that dealt explicitly with the immediate effects of introducing machinery, not with Ricardo’s chapter “On Gross and Net Revenue”. Both Malthus and McCulloch correctly identified the stimulus. So, why the mystery? Part of the reason would seem to be the absence of an explicit acknowledgement by Ricardo in the Sraffa edition of the Notes on Malthus that there was a Malthusian influence and, perhaps more substantially, his explicit denial in correspondence that he was following Malthus’s lead. Yet, as I show, his difference with Malthus was over the longer-term result of machinery’s introduction, not with its immediate effect of increasing net income and reducing gross income (and employment), which is the key point on which they now agreed and resulted in Ricardo’s introduction of the new chapter “On Machinery”. It is therefore likely that commentators have been thrown off the scent by Ricardo himself, but there is no compelling reason for continuing along the wrong paths.
Area:
Keywords: Ricardo, Machinery, Malthus, Barton
Please Login in order to download this file