Curating the Economics Canon: The Making of The New Palgrave
The New Palgrave: A Dictionary of Economics (Eatwell, Milgate & Newman, 1987) was a unique manifestation of organised collective reflection on the state of the discipline, shaped by the interactions between its three editors and a broad representation of leading economists. This paper offers an account of the encyclopedia’s editorial process, based on the rich and previously unexplored documentary record preserved in the Macmillan Archive, and complemented by an original interview with editor Murray Milgate. Rather than treating the encyclopedia as a finished intellectual product, the article focuses on its making, asking how editorial decisions were formulated, negotiated, and implemented over time. Drawing on internal reports with comments on drafts and correspondence with contributors, the paper investigates the forms of editorial intervention, particularly in the management of revisions and the handling of intellectual disagreements. The archival record shows that features often attributed solely to ideological design were also conditioned by practical circumstances, including contributor availability, missed deadlines, commercial expectations, and the limits of pre-internet publishing. It also clarifies the editors’ deliberate effort to situate contemporary economics in historical perspective, while showing that the historical narratives that emerged were only partially under editorial control. The New Palgrave thus appears less as a fixed manifesto than as the contingent product of collective editorial labour.
Area:
Keywords: The New Palgrave Dictionary of Economics, Editorial practices, Oral histories
Please Login in order to download this file