Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

Centring Women’s Voices? Testimony and Expertise at the Royal Commission on Equal Pay, 1944-1946

Chassonnery-Zaïgouche Cléo, London School of Economics and Political Science

In 1944, the British War Cabinet established a Royal Commission on Equal Pay to examine whether equal pay should be implemented for civil servants and across industries. While I have analysed the expert memoranda submitted to the Commission, less attention has been paid to the oral testimonies (auditions) given by women themselves—entrepreneurs, trade unionists, teachers, engineers, and others who appeared before the Commissioners. Drawing on hearing transcripts as primary sources, I contrast two forms of knowledge production at the Commission: the written memoranda from experts (mainly economists and medical experts) and the testimonies from women who appeared before the Commissioners, usually relying on their lived economic experiences and own expertise. This methodological approach shows how selection of sources can obscure women’s agency—their testimonies were heard but ultimately subordinated to “expert” knowledge in the final 1946 report, which rejected equal pay as a general principle. By centring women’s testimonies rather than treating them as secondary to expert contributions, this paper demonstrates how archival reconstruction can recover women’s articulation of economic principles and challenge the status of experience (and of the objective expert) in structured policy deliberations. It contributes to understanding both how women shaped economic policy debates and the mechanisms through which their contributions are marginalized in official narratives.

Area:

Keywords: Equal Pay