Towards tax simplification in the mid-nineteenth century. Luis María Pastor and the single tax debate
The aim of this work is to offer new insights into what has been a largely overlooked chapter in the history of economic thought: the single tax debate in the mid-nineteenth century. Two single tax proposals have received particular attention from historians of economic thought: the tax on land rent advocated by François Quesnay and the physiocrats in the eighteenth century, and the one promoted by Henry George in the late nineteenth century. However, the idea that the fiscal system should be based on a single tax had already re-emerged in a significant way in Europe in the mid-nineteenth century. Evidence of the diffusion of this idea among economists is provided by the understudied international congress on taxation held in Lausanne in 1860, whose participants concluded that it was desirable to adopt a single tax as the basis of the fiscal system. Debates over the benefit and ability-to-pay principles, as well as the preference for proportional or progressive taxation in the mid-nineteenth century, have been extensively studied. By contrast, little attention has been paid to the single tax debate. In this article, we shed light on these debates, particularly through the discussions at the congress of Lausanne in 1860. We also focus on the single tax proposed by one of its participants, the Spanish economist Luis María Pastor (Barcelona, 1804 – Madrid, 1872). Pastor was one of the most important economists in nineteenth-century Spain. He devoted much of his work to public finance and, in particular, to the question of taxation. Pastor achieved such recognition in this field that the American historian E. R. A. Seligman (1894, p. 110) described him as “the chief of the earlier writers on finance” in Spain. Pastor developed a novel tax theory. He proposed a single tax to be levied on the taxpayer’s social class and based on the benefit principle. Likewise, unlike most of his contemporaries, he believed that a single tax was feasible in practice. For this reason, he presented a plan to implement his single tax, specifically tailored to mid-nineteenth century Spain. In short, this work focuses on the single tax debates in mid-nineteenth century Europe and highlights the single tax proposed by Luis María Pastor, particularly because of its singularity. References Seligman, Edwin R. A. 1894. Progressive taxation in theory and practice. Baltimore: Press of Guggenheimer, Weil and Co.
Area:
Keywords: Single tax, Luis María Pastor, 19th century Europe
Please Login in order to download this file