The Specter of Emancipation: Slavery, Development and Black Labor in Northern U.S. Political Economy
This paper investigates how Northern U.S. economists conceptualized the relationship between slavery, emancipation and economic development in the two decades before the Civil War. Focusing on the writings of Henry Charles Carey, Francis Wayland, Stephen Colwell, William Elder and Erasmus Peshine Smith, the paper argues that, despite their moral and theoretical opposition to the institution of human bondage, in the 1840s and 1850s their reflection on slavery and emancipation moved first and foremost from the attempt to preserve cotton plantations and guarantee the command over black labor against the double threat posed by the slaves’ insubordination and the abolitionist movement. In particular, it was to counter the abolitionist movement’s radical call for an immediate, unconditional emancipation that Northern economists like Carey, Wayland and Colwell insisted on the need for a gradual, ordered and limited emancipation that could “prepare” slaves for freedom. However, in the increasingly polarized context of the 1850s, this meant postponing emancipation, issuing harsh attacks against abolitionists and even defending Southern slaveowners. Overall, then, the paper shows that, despite following Adam Smith in depicting capitalist development as the conceptual opposite of slavery, Northern economists ended up recognizing the compatibility between slavery and capitalism, at least in the short to medium term. [Please not that this paper is part of the session "History of Nineteenth Century Ideas of Development: US and France" proposed by Sofia Valeonti]
Area:
Keywords: U.S. Political Economy; Slavery; Development; Capitalism; Emancipation
Il paper è coperto da copyright. The paper is copyrighted.