Integrated History and Philosophy of Science for Economics
While integration of history and philosophy of economics is a desirable aim, it is very challenging to reach. As the history of the relationship between history of economics and economic methodology reveals, it also needs to be integration of the right kind. In this paper, we argue that, in pursuing this aim, philosophers and historians of economics should conceive of the relationship between history and philosophy of economics as iterative rather than inductive, thereby aligning with a recent methodological proposal from Integrated History and Philosophy of Science (&HPS), that is, Hasok Chang’s (2012) cyclical model of the relationship between history and philosophy of science. We support our claims by, first, presenting a historical sketch of the relationship between history and philosophy of economics to show that while the call for integrating both fields is not new, existing efforts were always accompanied by challenges of different kinds. Second, we examine three exemplary cases in which historical and philosophical approaches have been integrated to address both philosophical and historical questions about economics. The first exemplar is Marcel Boumans’ (2023) analysis of Jan Tinbergen’s 1930s business cycle modeling, in which Tinbergen transferred elements of dynamic equations from physics to economics. Boumans provides a discussion of philosophical concepts such as a “formal template” to show how history can inform philosophy by concretizing, revising, and supplementing these concepts. The second exemplar is Margaret Schabas’ (2008) use of existing philosophical insights about thought experiments to analyze David Hume’s views on monetary economics. The final exemplar is Mary Morgan’s (2006, 2012, ch. 4) refinement of the philosophical concept of model idealization based on a detailed historical analysis of the changing nature and role of the rationality assumption in economic models over time. We take those exemplars to be representative for the different ways in contemporary scholarship in which historians and philosophers of economics proceed iteratively to show how historical episodes can be better understood through a philosophical framework while philosophical concepts can be refined – albeit only provisionally – in light of concrete historical cases. In this way, they showcase in which way integrated work can provide the unique insights that might be useful not only for historians and philosophers of economics alike but also for economists themselves. References: Boumans, M. (2023). Materials selection in economic modeling. Synthese, 201(4), 125. Chang, H. (2012). Beyond case-studies: History as philosophy. In S. Mauskopf & T. Schmaltz (Eds.), Integrating History and Philosophy of Science: Problems and Prospects (pp. 109–124). Springer. Morgan, M. S. (2006). Economic man as model man: Ideal types, idealization and caricatures. Journal of the History of Economic Thought, 28(1), 1–27. Morgan, M. S. (2012). The World in the Model: How Economists Work and Think. Cambridge University Press. Schabas, M. (2008). Hume’s monetary thought experiments. Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part A, 39(2), 161–169.
Area:
Keywords: HPS, Integrated History and Philosophy of Science, History of Economics, Philosophy of Economics, Hasok Chang, Cyclical Model, Epistemic Iteration
Please Login in order to download this file