Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

Republicans’ Competing Visions of Development after the US Civil War

Valeonti Sofia, American University of Paris

At the end of Civil War, the United States had to decide upon the best policy to reconstruct the Union. The were three salient economic debates: 1) Should the country maintain the money that the Union issued to finance the war? 2) Should it diminish the high protective tariff adopted for the same purpose? 3) What should be the economic orientation of the South and the freedpeople’s role in it? In this article, I reconstruct the connections between these three key debates drawing directly from the writings and archival materials of political economists and politicians, such as Edward Atkinson, Stephen Colwell, Henry C. Carey, John Sherman, and Thaddeus Stevens. I aim to show that, beyond the contending answers to each question, what was at stake were two competing visions of U.S. capitalism. I identify two types of American economic development: U.S. national independence and U.S. international integration. Each is the outgrowth of a wholly different model of economic development. Advocates of national independence promoted a domestic market protected from competition with advance economies. They wanted to build a U.S. economy that would mainly export industrial products, not raw materials. On the other side, advocates of international integration envisioned the openness of the American economy, involving its commercial and capital integration. The policy recommendations of the main participants in the postbellum policy debate were conditioned by their visions of development. Those who wanted to promote national independence tended to support the fiat standard of the Civil War, a protective tariff, and a reorganization of labor of the south that would move this economy away from a plantation economy. On the other hand, those who favored international integration, preferred a specie standard, free trade, and the continuation of a southern plantation economy under a wage regime.

Area:

Keywords: US economic development, slavery, gold standard, tariff, free trade, fiat standard, free labor

Il paper è coperto da copyright. The paper is copyrighted.