Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

Stability and Development in Chicago’s Theory of the Individual

Dekker Erwin, Mercatus Center at George Mason University

To Frank Knight one of the key methodological problems for economics was the stability of the subject matter. He recognized that stability could be situated at the level of individual instincts, values, or preferences, but at the same time suggested that this was a gross misrepresentation of the true goal of individuals, and of the social nature of preferences if one referred to instincts. Following various Progressive economic thinkers Knight was convinced that the goal of individuals was not merely to satisfy (natural) preferences, but to fit in with one’s social group and if possible obtain better social preferences. This paper contextualizes Knight's ideas of individual preferences in relation to other economic thinkers in the first decades of the 20th century including Hazel Kyrk, Thorstein Veblen and Richard T. Ely, but also the social psychologists like Charles H. Cooley and George Herbert Mead who played a foundational role in the formation of American social science. The paper will suggest that the problems identified by Knight, remained a productive tension for a variety of later economists in the Chicago School of Economics. Economists like George Stigler, Milton Friedman, Gary Becker and relatedly James Buchanan, all grappled with the question of the stability of preferences, and the dynamic nature of individual identity and preferences.

Area:

Keywords: Chicago School; Frank Knight; Preferences; Individualism