The Palimpsest of the Popes: Interest and Usury Behind the Vow of Poverty (13th Century and After)
From Gregory IX in the first half of the 13th century to John XXII at the beginning of the 14th century, none of the bulls and decretals of the popes mentioned below directly addressed the question of money lending and usury. What was at issue was the vow of poverty taken by the Franciscan friars, its applicability, and the sometimes violent conflicts it generated within and outside the order. And yet, in their attempts to tip the balance one way or the other, or simply to reduce the violence of the conflicts, the contributions of these successive Popes (Gregory IX, Innocent IV, Nicholas III, Clement V and John XXII) would lead to an alternative understanding of interest-bearing loans, foreign to the classical argument on usury as developed by Thomas Aquinas in the 1270’s in the De Malo or in the Summa Theologiae. This series of texts from the Holy See is therefore a palimpsest, in which these interpretations of money lending will emerge, penned by other authors, from John Duns Scotus and Gerald Odonis in the first years of the 14th century to Juan de Medina and Leonardus Lessius, respectively at the end of the 16th and at the beginning of the 17th century. The key to this palimpsest was a refinement and an internal division of the concept of use and of its relationship to property: dealing with the vow of poverty requires not only a discussion of the prohibition of property according to the types of goods concerned, but also an assessment of the way and extent to which their use is legitimate.
Area:
Keywords: Scholastic economics; Usury; Interest: Money loans; Poverty
Please Login in order to download this file