Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

Ethics, Economics and Reality: The Ethical Foundations of Cambridge Social Ontology

Ragusis Andonis, Girton College, University of Cambridge | CBR, Judge Business School | CISE, ARU

Next year marks thirty years since the publication of Tony Lawson’s ‘Economics and Reality’, inviting renewed reflection on its place in debates over economic methodology and the history of economic thought. This paper situates the book within the development of the Cambridge Social Ontology Group, understood as one of the most recent iterations of the Cambridge tradition in economics, and traces the emergence of its ethical dimension in a historical context. Among Lawson’s contributions is the development of an ethical theory known as Critical Ethical Naturalism (CEN). Although formally introduced in 2015, ethical considerations can be traced back to the group’s work in the 1990s. ‘Economics and Reality’ itself includes a chapter on economic policy that already reflects an ethical perspective aligned with what would later be articulated as CEN. There, Lawson critiques the moral subjectivism of mainstream economics and advances a form of moral realism grounded in human nature, articulated through the idea of shared human objectives, or ‘real interests’, encompassing common needs and motives. Fully grasping Cambridge Social Ontology (CSO) requires engaging with CEN, which remains a relatively underexplored dimension of the project. Attending to CEN is essential for understanding not only key aspects of CSO’s critique of mainstream economics but also elements of Lawson’s intellectual orientation that have shaped his engagement with the history of economic thought, particularly in his interpretations of Keynes and Hayek. The interconnectedness of ontology, ethics, and economics was already evident in ‘Economics and Reality’. In this sense, CEN constitutes a vital contribution to both ethics and political economy. With respect to the latter, it can be understood as part of a broader project rooted in the Cambridge tradition, aimed at reviving political economy as a comprehensive social science integrating economic, social, and ethical theorising.

Area:

Keywords: Economics and Reality; Tony Lawson; Cambridge Tradition; Ontology; Ethics

Please Login in order to download this file